When do you need to make an Strength (Athletics) check to climb when you have a climb speed?

\ $ \begingroup\ $

When the outcome of an action linked to climbing is uncertain

The rules for ability checks, in general, state ( emphasis mine ) :

The DM calls for an ability discipline when a character or monster attempts an action ( other than an attack ) that has a chance of failure. When the outcome is uncertain, the dice determine the results.

This means that whenever the result of an action linked to climbing is uncertain, you should roll a Strength ( Athletics ) check, which would get advantage from the potion ‘s effect.

Looking at the rules for climbing focal ratio you quoted, the climbing speed itself does n’t nullify the challenge of climbing on something, it simply allows you to climb faster and further than you normally would with precisely your normal apparent motion amphetamine .
That ‘s why there ‘s besides the second gear impression of the potion : while, as written, it does n’t make you spiderman, it still makes it easier for you to climb on material. Up to you to decide on what season you want to give to the advantage ( does it give you the skills of a veteran crampon ? does it make your hands slightly stick to walls ? does it let you see where it ‘s easier to grab the surface ? )

furthermore, the rules quoted from the Monster Manual practice to monsters with climbing speed, which does not implicitely make it apply to player characters. For those, we can alone use the general rules for how climb works.

It is besides good to note that the effects from the potion are drastically different from enchantment effects such as Spider Climb : the enchantment allows to climb on surfaces in many situations where you normally would n’t be able to, while the potion only increases the odds that you ‘ll manage to climb on a surface you would normally be able to climb .
Deciding what counts as a “ check you make to climb ” is improving to the DM. The distinctive roller for this would be for climbing unmanageable walls, trees or other elements that would make for a difficult climb for one reason or another .
other typical rolls linked to climbing would be to resist some external force trying to make you fall from the wall you ‘re climbing or presently holding on to, or trying to grab person ( or something ) while keeping your grip. Do note that those are in a grey area, as there is no clear definition of what is and is n’t considered in “ climbing ”. As a musician, best practice is to discuss any of those specific situations with your DM advance .

reservoir : https://meopari.com
Category : Blog